Steelers' Kaleb Johnson Now Faces 1 Potential Way Onto The Field

The Pittsburgh Steelers do not need Kaleb Johnson to become the featured back in 2026, but they may still need him to become something useful on game day. Johnson’s rookie season did not go the way anyone expected. The Steelers used a third-round pick on him in the 2025 NFL Draft after a dominant career at Iowa, but his first year in Pittsburgh quickly became more about patience than production. He finished with just 28 carries for 69 yards and one catch for nine yards, while also spending time inactive late in the season.

That makes his second year important. Johnson is no longer the exciting rookie with a clean slate. He is now a young player trying to prove that his college production can still translate, even if the path to touches is not wide open. That was part of the discussion on Steelers Standard, when insider Brian Batko looked at whether Johnson could still find a specific role in Pittsburgh’s offense.

"If he can get a hat on game days, which special teams will probably factor into that, I wonder if they can find a role for him, even if it’s [a] short-yardage banger," Batko said.

That is probably the most realistic version of Johnson’s 2026 role right now.

Jaylen Warren and Rico Dowdle are expected to lead the Steelers’ backfield. Warren has earned trust through toughness, contact balance, and receiving ability. Dowdle gives Pittsburgh another physical veteran runner who can handle early-down work. That leaves Johnson fighting for a smaller job, and that job may only exist if he proves he can do more than carry the ball.

The phrase “get a hat” is the key. A third running back who does not play special teams has a hard time being active on Sundays. Johnson learned that the hard way as a rookie. His special teams mistake against the Seattle Seahawks in Week 2 followed him for much of the season, and he did not get enough offensive chances afterward to change the conversation.

That is why special teams cannot be treated like a side issue.

If Johnson wants to become Pittsburgh’s short-yardage option, he first has to convince the coaching staff he can help on coverage units, return units, or any other phase that justifies a game-day uniform. Travis Homer has built a career doing exactly that. Eli Heidenreich also brings versatility that could matter on special teams. That puts pressure on Johnson to show value beyond the backfield.

The short-yardage role still makes sense. Johnson is listed at 6-foot-1 and 224 pounds, and his Iowa tape showed a runner who could build momentum, finish through contact, and punish defenses once he got downhill. He rushed for 1,537 yards and 21 touchdowns in his final college season. That version of Johnson looked like a player built for cold-weather football and tough late-game situations.

The Steelers could use that kind of runner.

Steelers Need Johnson To Earn Trust First

The Steelers’ offense will have plenty of high-profile pieces under Mike McCarthy, but hidden roles can still decide games.

Short-yardage carries are not glamorous. Third-and-1 and fourth-and-1 touches do not always show up as explosive plays. However, they extend drives, protect field position, and help an offense avoid putting everything on the quarterback. If Johnson can become trusted in those moments, his season can still have real value. That trust has to be earned.

A previous SteelerNation story noted that Johnson’s clearest path to a roster spot may come through special teams and proving he can be more than a developmental running back. That is exactly where this conversation sits now. Johnson’s draft status still matters, but it will not carry him forever. New coaches tend to care more about usefulness than investment.

That is why training camp and preseason will be huge. Johnson does not need to beat out Warren or Dowdle to matter. He needs to carve out a role that only he fills. If he can protect the football, run with power, handle short-yardage snaps, and contribute on special teams, he becomes a lot easier to keep active.

If he cannot, the numbers get difficult. The Steelers have too many players competing for limited game-day spots. A running back buried on the depth chart has to bring something extra. For Johnson, that extra value could be short-yardage power, but Batko’s point is important. It only matters if he gets a helmet on Sundays.

Johnson still has talent. He still has size. He still has a college résumé that explains why Pittsburgh drafted him.

Now he needs a role.

A short-yardage banger may not sound like a star job, but for Johnson, it could be the role that keeps his Steelers future alive.

#SteelerNation